Makers of Award-winning Role Playing Games › Forums › Arcanis: The Shattered Empires › Arcanis: Rules & Rulings › Do spells with range like 10′ Radius provoke?
- This topic has 30 replies, 10 voices, and was last updated 10 years, 11 months ago by frootsnax.
- AuthorPosts
- July 9, 2015 at 1:59 pm #151915AnonymousInactive
I thought I’d start a new thread looking for an official answer on this as it is pretty critical.
Do spells with ranges like “10′ Radius” provoke free strikes? Some people (including me) think no because it is no different than “0′ (10′ Radius)” or “Self (10′ Radius)”. Others think it does because it is missing the 0′ or Self descriptor.
What is the official ruling?
If it does provoke then all spells with such ranges need to have the radius expanded or else the spell is useless because the mage will be dead before the spell goes off.
July 9, 2015 at 2:15 pm #268950AnonymousInactiveTo clarify:
According to rules, only spells with range 0′, Self, or Melee do not provoke Free Strikes when cast in melee.
Spells like Channeling and Rebuke have a range of 10′ Radius, with no mention of 0′, Self, or Melee which implies that they DO provoke.
The ranges of these spells is so small that it means that you effectively have to provoke in order to cast them, reducing their utility.
Should the ranges of these be 0′ (10′ Radius) instead of 10′ Radius?
July 9, 2015 at 7:59 pm #268955frootsnaxParticipantI think they’re really self (10′)
July 9, 2015 at 9:27 pm #268960AnonymousInactiveI agree with Eric.
July 10, 2015 at 12:42 am #268964AnonymousInactivewell bring it up at the next go round on rules edits, as it stand the Rules as written mix things that are written that exact same way that should incur a free strike (in my opinion since we are expressing opinions)
July 10, 2015 at 1:27 pm #268968AnonymousInactivewell bring it up at the next go round on rules edits, as it stand the Rules as written mix things that are written that exact same way that should incur a free strike (in my opinion since we are expressing opinions)
What things with ranges like that do you think should incur free strikes?
In my opinion:
Spells:- No: Rebuke, Shield of Enduring Will, Dolphin Chant (adapted from Melee), Grey Mists, Righteous Edict, Silent No Longer (adapted from Self), Whirlwind of Blades, Channeling, Ghostly Legion, Rattle the Bones, Serpent’s Hiss, Shared Sacrifice[/*:m]
- Maybe: Flash (I would say no but it starts as cone which does provoke), Revelation, Ward of Protection, Blessed Rain, Fog Cloud, Ring of Fire, Sense Blood, Ward of Denial, With One Voice (I would say no but it starts as cone which does provoke), Zealot’s Fervor[/*:m]
- Irrelevant: Ward of Privacy (1 min speed)[/*:m]
- Unclear adaptation range: Deeper Understanding, Manipulate the Senses, Whispers of Terror[/*:m]
The spells that I note as “unclear adaptation range” start with a range such as 30′ (1 Target) but have an adaptation that has a range stated something like “all Targets within 10′ Radius”. I assume the original range applies and it is just changing the “target” portion (eg 30′ (10′ Radius)) but it is not explicit (unless I’m missing a general rule somewhere). If I’m correct on the range, then they clearly do provoke.
While searching for these, I noticed that Ward of Protection has an adaptation that needs errata. The spell starts as 10′ Radius and the adaptation says it becomes 10′ Radius. I’m assuming it should be “increase the radius by 10′”.
Talents:
- No: With the Eyes of Illiir, LMT (Wicked Snap), Bloodline of Stone T3, The Crushing Waves, The Tempest[/*:m]
Since there is absolutely nothing I can find that I think should provoke (just some “maybe” spells) and there are lots of things that I strongly feel should not provoke, I would definitely like to see errata saying that all things given range of “X’ Radius” are really “Self (X’ Radius)” (or “0′ (X’ Radius)”).
July 10, 2015 at 9:32 pm #268988AnonymousInactiveyeah, any thing on your list(s) that counts as an attack is on my list of things that provoke
July 10, 2015 at 9:44 pm #268990AnonymousInactiveyeah, any thing on your list(s) that counts as an attack is on my list of things that provoke
Seriously? An attack spell that provokes every time (or almost every time) you cast it is completely useless. The only way that would be balanced is if these attack spells were more powerful to make up for provoking and being very short range (but they aren’t).
Exactly why do you think these should provoke but all of the spells with Self (X’ Radius) or 0′ (X’ Radius) should not? I don’t understand your reasoning at all. If attack spells were meant to provoke when used then there wouldn’t be an exception given in the book for point blank spells.
Until this is officially clarified, I’ll probably just avoid these spells as I would likely get irritated if a GM tried telling me they provoke when cast as I don’t see any possible logical argument for them doing so (just the nitpicking that 0′ or Self were left off the range entry (when we all know there’s plenty of similar small errata in the books) – these are no different than any other non-range aoe spell/ability).
July 10, 2015 at 10:26 pm #268992AnonymousInactiveholy cow man, you are acting like incurring a free strike is the end of the world. bottom line is they aren’t, they don’t even affect the results of your spell casting.
The bottom line for me is that any spell that is an attack spell (and honestly most spells that are ranged buffs or misc spells) that operates at range should probably incur a free strike.
and keep in mind that this isn’t just spells but any ranged attack
July 10, 2015 at 10:31 pm #268993AnonymousInactiveJust to be clear and to make sure I understand things, I always thought that if you did a ranged attack or cast pretty much any spell within melee range of an active opponent (with a melee weapon in hand) he had a shot at you. Now I’m at work and don’t have the rules in front of me. If I cast and he hits me what is the effect?
July 10, 2015 at 10:34 pm #268994AnonymousInactiveholy cow man, you are acting like incurring a free strike is the end of the world. bottom line is they aren’t, they don’t even affect the results of your spell casting.
The bottom line for me is that any spell that is an attack spell (and honestly most spells that are ranged buffs or misc spells) that operates at range should probably incur a free strike.
and keep in mind that this isn’t just spells but any ranged attack
But these aren’t ranged attacks (that’s the whole point). For a 5′ Radius attack spell, incurring free strikes is the end of the world as every possible target can hit you (even for 10′ Radius, it means likely taking a fair amount of damage).
July 10, 2015 at 10:37 pm #268995AnonymousInactiveJust to be clear and to make sure I understand things, I always thought that if you did a ranged attack or cast pretty much any spell within melee range of an active opponent (with a melee weapon in hand) he had a shot at you. Now I’m at work and don’t have the rules in front of me. If I cast and he hits me what is the effect?
If the spell/attack is 0′, Self, or Melee then there is no free strike granted. That’s the crux of the argument – some people are claiming that “10′ Radius” provokes but “0′ (10′ Radius)” and “Self (10′ Radius)” don’t even though all of them are 0′ range.
I think (not positive) the “only” effect is taking damage. If you are Vanquished, I’m not sure if the spell still goes off or not.
July 10, 2015 at 10:39 pm #268996AnonymousInactivewhat happens when you incur a free strike from spell casting:
if you get hit you take damage
IF your casting an interuptable spell, your clock is pushed for every 5 ticks of damage, or you lose your spell if you take a wound
July 10, 2015 at 10:41 pm #268997AnonymousInactiveSo you still get the spell off then? Thanks Josh.
July 10, 2015 at 10:42 pm #268998AnonymousInactiveTo be clear I am referring to standard spells not the interruptible kind.
![\":)\"](\"{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_smile.gif\" "\\"Smile\\"")
- AuthorPosts
- The forum ‘Arcanis: Rules & Rulings’ is closed to new topics and replies.