Makers of Award-winning Role Playing Games › Forums › Arcanis: The Shattered Empires › Arcanis: Players Commons › The wish list
- This topic has 33 replies, 15 voices, and was last updated 12 years, 6 months ago by frootsnax.
- AuthorPosts
- March 28, 2014 at 12:44 am #151118AnonymousInactive
So as players what things are on your wishlist to be included in future books? Keep in mind guys this isn’t to make demands, but if they happen to have a page or so of space in a future book what would you want there.
I’ll start mine with the battle skill and what it already talks about. I want to see at least a simple version of the Battle system that is supposed to be in the Chronicler’s Guide when it gets released. The second item I’d like to see is some of these siege weapons we can use the battle skill to operate, I’ve already pondered the small ones like a roman scorpion or the insanity of a cannon.
While I’m not sure how to pull it off yet I’d like to see a system to really differentiate armors from each other. They feel like they are all the same, so why not grab the one you can use with the best AR and lowest bulk you can get. I envision something to allow for armors to be better vs some attack types and weaker vs others, the classic chain stops a sword cut but its flexibility makes it weak vs a mace blow. I can see this done with more liberal use of qualities or a maneuver system.
I’d like to know more about the “bigger picture”. I’ve heard talk of the cosmology being something along the lines of a source of creation and the darkness further out, with the world of Arcanis in the middle. How about what do we know about the continents other than the broken history of known lands.
Lastly is more of a project for our enterprising and knowledgeable fans. Put the campaign arcs into a novel or novella format following a single group through the events. I have always felt like I really don’t know the setting because I haven’t played the old campaign and I can’t get to the events for the current one. I think it would be highly entertaining and educational about the world to follow a troupe through the living history as many of the old hands here have done. I could see it being very similar to the original DragonLance novels, as they were just an adaptation of their game.
March 28, 2014 at 1:23 am #261237AnonymousInactiveWhat I’ve often wanted is a good summary of the setting. I tend to like condensed information (so facts minus most of the fluff).
What major events happened in which regions at what times (in a timeline format per nation)? What are the most important details of the nation (in a bullet-point format or similar)? What are the important differences between regions within a nation?
What are major details that aren’t covered in the current system books? I’ve read Codex Arcanis but I still often see references to knowledge or events I know nothing about (I was never part of the old campaign either).
———————————————-
All of my players are new to Arcanis and 1 or 2 are new to RPGs. What my players have most often asked for (a few of them anyway) is a better Codex Arcanis section of the rulebook. Something easy to digest (so a mix of facts and fluff) that is written well and better organized (I think they mean fewer flipping back and forth to understand things). One player insists that the writing in the Codex Arcanis section of the main rulebook is horrible and hard to get through (I can’t really say as I’ve read far worse gaming books).
March 28, 2014 at 10:49 am #261250AnonymousInactiveWhat I’ve often wanted is a good summary of the setting. I tend to like condensed information (so facts minus most of the fluff).
What major events happened in which regions at what times (in a timeline format per nation)? What are the most important details of the nation (in a bullet-point format or similar)? What are the important differences between regions within a nation?
What are major details that aren’t covered in the current system books? I’ve read Codex Arcanis but I still often see references to knowledge or events I know nothing about (I was never part of the old campaign either).
———————————————-
All of my players are new to Arcanis and 1 or 2 are new to RPGs. What my players have most often asked for (a few of them anyway) is a better Codex Arcanis section of the rulebook. Something easy to digest (so a mix of facts and fluff) that is written well and better organized (I think they mean fewer flipping back and forth to understand things). One player insists that the writing in the Codex Arcanis section of the main rulebook is horrible and hard to get through (I can’t really say as I’ve read far worse gaming books).
THIS THIS THIS!
I want short, ebooks through drive through RPG. You hit me with a 30(?) page book, I’d drop 5 bucks without thinking.
I love to see lots of smaller books with one large book a year.
March 28, 2014 at 1:58 pm #261257AnonymousInactiveOne player insists that the writing in the Codex Arcanis section of the main rulebook is horrible and hard to get through (I can’t really say as I’ve read far worse gaming books).
How so? Seriously asking here..
March 28, 2014 at 4:50 pm #261260AnonymousInactiveWhat I’ve often wanted is a good summary of the setting. I tend to like condensed information (so facts minus most of the fluff).Keep in mind that one of the selling points in Arcanis is that there are so few unambiguous facts. Most of the facts are hidden behind layers of “fluff.” And figuring out what fluff is right and what fluff is wrong is part of the fun. Now, some facts are unambiguous to our characters… In 1070 IC, King Osric calls the 6th Crusade of Light. Or… On such-and-such date the battle of
began and on this date it officially ended. Things like that. But even those become more and more obscured as we look further back in time. So while something like this would be nice, as we got further and further away from Arcanis’ present, the less and less trustworthy it would become. Scott
March 28, 2014 at 5:21 pm #261261AnonymousInactiveWhat I’d like most to see are the Historica Geographica Series greatly expanded, with at least one coming out a year. I know we’re getting the Blessed Lands and the rereleased Ssethregore sometime between now and September, and there is the Kio-mini Sourcebook coming out in a vaguely similar timeline, but I just want more (to quote the internet PUT IT IN MY EYES!!!!). As much as the epic volume of the Codex Arcanis 2 (the Revengening?) interests me, I would greatly prefer to see each section get its own book similar to how Canceri and Ssethregore did. I’d love to see a Khitani Book, a Coryani Book, a Milandir/Almeric book, a new Legacy of Damnation/Unsealed Lands Book, a Western Lands/Uggur/whatever else book, etc. These more ‘personal’ documents give more room to explore the cultures and histories of these nations rather than having to crowbar them into a much more (relatively) limited page count.
Also, as stated before, I’m FAR more willing to buy 5x $15 books over a year than a single $50 book, if only because I’m stupid and can’t do math
It is harder to rationalize single big-money spendings, but much easier to rationalize smaller ones spread out over a year, even if the final monies are the same.Another thing I’d LOVE to see would be a new Psionics Unbound-type book, and (as a player of a Divine caster) that Codex of Faith idea which was dropped a while ago, but hasn’t made it (officially) past the title and general idea stage from what I can tell. We’re already getting an Elder Sorcery book from the Kickstarter, so these types of books seem completely possible to me.
March 28, 2014 at 10:56 pm #261266AnonymousInactiveI realize that this might be a little too specific, but I would really love to see more information on the Vrain. It has always seemed to me that there are some really great stories to tell there…certainly an opportunity for some dungeon delve modules.
March 29, 2014 at 12:05 am #261268frootsnaxParticipantBooks?
What I’d love to see most is an Arcanis version of Dread Bloodlines. DB was a Ravenloft book that came out of the White Wolf 3.X era and used the idea of fleshing out regions through the most prominent families and how they might be used as adventure seeds.
An Arcanis version might illuminate royal and imperial life through those who surround the King and Emperor. And show the life of the powerful outside of those centers of power with an example of powerful regional players and or how the merchant houses interact in a place like Censure or the First City.
A geographical survey heavy on Maps would also be highly desire able to me.
March 29, 2014 at 4:40 am #261279AnonymousInactiveOne player insists that the writing in the Codex Arcanis section of the main rulebook is horrible and hard to get through (I can’t really say as I’ve read far worse gaming books).
How so? Seriously asking here..
I’ll ask for more details and get back to you…
March 29, 2014 at 4:42 am #261280AnonymousInactiveWhat I’ve often wanted is a good summary of the setting. I tend to like condensed information (so facts minus most of the fluff).Keep in mind that one of the selling points in Arcanis is that there are so few unambiguous facts. Most of the facts are hidden behind layers of “fluff.” And figuring out what fluff is right and what fluff is wrong is part of the fun. Now, some facts are unambiguous to our characters… In 1070 IC, King Osric calls the 6th Crusade of Light. Or… On such-and-such date the battle of
began and on this date it officially ended. Things like that. But even those become more and more obscured as we look further back in time. So while something like this would be nice, as we got further and further away from Arcanis’ present, the less and less trustworthy it would become. Scott
Yep and I’m fine with that. I’d be fine with splitting facts from “we think this happened” (true or not) but I’d also be fine with everything listed together (so it’s more unclear what’s true and what’s only thought to be true). I’d love something like a bulleted list of brief “facts” and a reference where to read more about it.
March 29, 2014 at 7:34 am #261282frootsnaxParticipantSo as players what things are on your wishlist to be included in future books? Keep in mind guys this isn’t to make demands, but if they happen to have a page or so of space in a future book what would you want there.
A few pages?
Rules for the creation of Environmental Trials. They get a brief mention in the Bestiary … but we have no idea how to build and value one with encounters. =/
For a few pages there is nothing more that I want (and for me putting that ahead of maps is saying something).
March 29, 2014 at 3:55 pm #261285AnonymousInactiveYep and I’m fine with that. I’d be fine with splitting facts from “we think this happened” (true or not) but I’d also be fine with everything listed together (so it’s more unclear what’s true and what’s only thought to be true). I’d love something like a bulleted list of brief “facts” and a reference where to read more about it.
So I’ve been toying around with this idea for a while, now. And I finally decided to kick it off. I started this timeline wiki…. http://arcanistimeline.wikidot.com/There’s only a few items in it at the moment. And I’ve only pulled items that are listed in the free Codex Arcanis PDF. (mostly I’m copying from the timeline on page 15.) What I don’t want this to turn into is an online version of PCI copyrighted material or spoilers. (So if PCI has any objections to what”s out there, just let me know and I’ll close it down.) Right now, I’m the only editor. And like I said, it’s just a fraction of the information that it could contain. But is this what you had in mind?
Scott
March 29, 2014 at 4:12 pm #261286AnonymousInactiveBut is this what you had in mind?
Yes. For the timeline piece, that’s pretty much exactly what I had in mind. Now if it were only more complete… ;-P
March 29, 2014 at 4:28 pm #261287AnonymousInactiveSsethregore also has a good timeline in it
March 29, 2014 at 5:44 pm #261292AnonymousInactiveSsethregore also has a good timeline in it
That was sort of my point. There are a few timelines in various books and further details in text. I’d love to see it consolidated into a useful single timeline. There is (or at least was) an insanely detailed timeline online for Shadowrun that pulled minimal “historic” details from every available source. This is the type of thing I’d love to see and, as long as the details were pretty basic (and reference the actual source), I don’t think PCI would have an issue (but only they can answer that for sure).
- AuthorPosts
- The forum ‘Arcanis: Players Commons’ is closed to new topics and replies.