Makers of Award-winning Role Playing Games › Forums › Witch Hunter 2nd edition › Witch Hunter: Rules & Rulings › Collated Errata + FAQ queries
- This topic has 58 replies, 16 voices, and was last updated 11 years, 6 months ago by Anonymous.
- AuthorPosts
- January 29, 2014 at 2:38 am #255952AnonymousInactive
For the purpose of effects like Power of Faith, and of rites like Halo of Awe, Judgment, and Holy Weapon, should we assume that an opponent’s Hell’s Favor is equal to its Damnation?
Envious/Covetous sin on page 144: Does the roll result which gets copied have to apply to a roll of the same type (as in the first sentence) or can it apply to any roll (as in the last sentence)?
Can the animist’s Knit the Flesh rite target anyone or just the shaman himself? The effect suggests the latter, but the Boost suggests the former.
Any chance of getting these answered before Winter Fantasy? The other questions I had in this thread were also unanswered, but they won’t affect starting characters.
January 29, 2014 at 3:51 pm #255992AnonymousInactiveFor the purpose of effects like Power of Faith, and of rites like Halo of Awe, Judgment, and Holy Weapon, should we assume that an opponent’s Hell’s Favor is equal to its Damnation?
Envious/Covetous sin on page 144: Does the roll result which gets copied have to apply to a roll of the same type (as in the first sentence) or can it apply to any roll (as in the last sentence)?
Can the animist’s Knit the Flesh rite target anyone or just the shaman himself? The effect suggests the latter, but the Boost suggests the former.
Any chance of getting these answered before Winter Fantasy? The other questions I had in this thread were also unanswered, but they won’t affect starting characters.
Power of Faith (et al): These trigger on Damnation, so I do not understand the reference to Hell’s Favor.
Envious: Same type, not sure what I was thinking when I wrote that last sentence.
Knit the Flesh: It can heal others
January 29, 2014 at 10:12 pm #256024AnonymousInactiveFor the purpose of effects like Power of Faith, and of rites like Halo of Awe, Judgment, and Holy Weapon, should we assume that an opponent’s Hell’s Favor is equal to its Damnation?
Any chance of getting these answered before Winter Fantasy? The other questions I had in this thread were also unanswered, but they won’t affect starting characters.
Power of Faith (et al): These trigger on Damnation, so I do not understand the reference to Hell’s Favor.
That’s the problem. I’ve looked at all the NPCs listed in the book, and none of them have Damnation listed as part of their statistics. I don’t think that it’s supposed to be impossible to use Power of Faith, Halo of Awe, etc., but that’s how it stands now.
January 29, 2014 at 11:37 pm #256028AnonymousInactiveThat’s the problem. I’ve looked at all the NPCs listed in the book, and none of them have Damnation listed as part of their statistics. I don’t think that it’s supposed to be impossible to use Power of Faith, Halo of Awe, etc., but that’s how it stands now.
I see that. I looks like my coauthor removed those from the stat blocks and I failed to notice. I will examine it and provide a small errata soon.
February 3, 2014 at 4:26 am #256172AnonymousInactiveAll rites and effects that check against Damnation, also check against Hell’s Favor – using the higher of the two values if the target possesses both. Anything that states it does not function against creatures without Damnation also functions against creatures with Hell’s Favor.
February 3, 2014 at 5:18 pm #256180AnonymousInactiveExcellent; thanks very much!
February 25, 2014 at 10:56 am #257472AnonymousInactiveA few questions:
1. Can I spend elective skill points on Sorcerous skills (e.g. Hermieticism, Prayer, etc)? as professional skills?
2. What action type is it to use command to shake people out of fear effects?Cheerio,
Ben
February 25, 2014 at 12:54 pm #257478AnonymousInactiveA few questions:
1. Can I spend elective skill points on Sorcerous skills (e.g. Hermieticism, Prayer, etc)? as professional skills?
2. What action type is it to use command to shake people out of fear effects?Cheerio,
Ben
1) Sorcererous Skills aren’t Professional Skills, they have their own category.
2) I don’t know this one off hand.
February 25, 2014 at 3:57 pm #257493AnonymousInactiveI’ll second all that Harlequin has to say, but…
2. What action type is it to use command to shake people out of fear effects?
I’d argue you could use Charm/Persuade or Command/Leadership to do this. I’d set the Difficulty pretty high (prolly 5), especially since characters already get a second chance after 2 rounds. This might also be a good candidate for a talent (greater). But as Harlequin said, there isn’t a specific focus geared to doing this. Does there need to be though? Use your best judgement on the Difficulty and let them take a shot.
Tom
February 26, 2014 at 8:35 am #257587AnonymousInactive1. so I can’t spend elective points on sorcerous skills? Seems harsh on spellcasting characters.
2…
Leadership can also be used to overcome the effects of Fear checks by others (see page 190). The commander must be capable of giving such orders: a Witch Hunter fleeing from a ghost is not a particularly inspiring sight to those he would lead. The character rolls Leadership (with all interaction bonuses and penalties such as for commanding multiple targets) and adds any successes to the original results of the commanded characters.But it doesn’t say what action type. Quick? Complex?
February 26, 2014 at 12:22 pm #257591AnonymousInactiveAs you noted, I don’t think the action type is given. I’d allow it as a quick action since the command is simple (“Stand and fight, you cowardly knaves!” – or nicer as the case may be).
February 26, 2014 at 6:20 pm #257626AnonymousInactive2…
Leadership can also be used to overcome the effects of Fear checks by others…Oh good. So I’m right and wrong. That’s an improvement.

Of course, this suggests Leadership can help YOU overcome the effects of fear, not motivate your companion out of it. (But I’d allow that, too.)
But it doesn’t say what action type. Quick? Complex?
Hmmm…it’s pretty much left up to the GM, but I’m gonna say Complex. If it’s a quick action, it doesn’t really cost the character anything. In fact, you might as well just allow a +1d to Fear rolls for every 2 ranks in Leadership and just be done with it. Right now, you fail your fear roll and get to roll again after 2 rounds (or, in more gamist terms, lose your next 2 actions). Leadership suddenly gives you an immediate second chance on your next action. Making it a complex Action to shake off the effects of fear still gives it some teeth.
OTOH, when it comes to motivating your companions to shake off fear effects, I’d leave it up to the player’s description. A slap across the face and a “move it, soldier!” would be a Quick Action. Taking a moment to calm you companion down while restraining him so he doesn’t bolt from cover where he is sure to give away your position to something big and hungry would most definitely be a Complex action. If you want to be even more judicious, I’d let the player do it as a Quick Action for a 1d Wager. That gives her a choice in the matter and lets her gauge the risks against her abilities.
In fact, that’s for that. I think that will be going in the fear cheat sheet when I get to it.

Tom
February 26, 2014 at 7:58 pm #257641AnonymousInactive1. so I can’t spend elective points on sorcerous skills? Seems harsh on spellcasting characters.
Not particularly. Spellcasting isn’t the norm that it is in some games.
John
March 18, 2014 at 1:24 am #259601AnonymousInactiveSo a little confusion for Foci.
I get the impression that the Performs are each different skills. The different Performs are each an individual skill?
Does this apply to Scholarship as well?
Melee or Ranged?
Any other skills?
March 18, 2014 at 4:54 pm #259665AnonymousInactiveI see the confusion. The Perform skill instructs you to choose a focci. the implication of this is that you can make perform checks with that focus. However, the Skill Foci section on page 107 says:
A character with levels in a skill may make use of all of its Foci.
However, Speak Language has its own special section that says that each language is tracked separately. Perform does not. So I’d be inclined to let you use your perform ranks on any of the individual foci. (As ridiculous as it may sound to say that ranks in Perform(Dance) would carry over into Perform(Wind Instruments).)
Eric: Any chance you can clear up whether this was the intention or if the “Special” section was accidentally left off?
Scott
- AuthorPosts
- The forum ‘Witch Hunter: Rules & Rulings’ is closed to new topics and replies.