Viewing 15 posts - 91 through 105 (of 186 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #266591
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    I have the same reading as Eric.

    Passive of 18 is the equivalent of a passive stat of 3 and 3 ranks.

    If you also added passive charisma then it would be equivalent of 6 ranks of Arcanium + passive charisma

    Too much for base rune IMHO but I too will wait for the Stat Monkey to speak with his poorly spelt wisdom

    #267942
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    For the spell Ward Against the Unnatural, on ARPG p.442 there is a special adaptation for the Blood tradition. Does this Blood adaptation work against any type of person or creature, or is it only against one individual Undead, Shade, or Infernal as per the base spell?

    I interpret it as being against any type of person or creature for whom the caster posses blood, but the adaptation is not explicit.

    #267944
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    For the spell Steal Water, on ARPG p.430, there is a special adaptation for the Blood and Heritage traditions to enhance single a Blood spell. In what time frame does this follow-up need to be cast to take advantage of the bonus?

    I could see it being any of the below:
    * The Blood spell is cast as part of the Steal Water spell–though how they’d be combined isn’t clear from the Steal Water description.
    * The Blood spell must be part of the caster’s next action.
    * The Blood spell must be cast within a certain number of ticks–though the number of ticks needs to be determined.
    * The Blood spell must be cast during the same scene.

    #267945
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    For the Talents Rudimentary Prayers and Rudimentary Spell Casting (see ARPG pp.204-05), must the single spell selected be Tier I, or may it be any Tier?

    I infer that it should have to be a Tier I spell, but the talents are not explicit.

    #267946
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    Does the ability to use Arcanum(Sorcery) untrained via the Bloodline Talent Sarish Is Known to His Chosen (ARPG p.222) count for the prerequisite of having Arcanum (Sorcery) as a trained skill?

    It is technically not trained, but since val’Mehans with that Bloodline Talent can cast spells instinctively, I can easily see it being a sufficient substitute. This question matters mostly for learning spellcasting, which val’Mehans can already somewhat do via their bloodline, but most spellcasting talents (e.g., Arcane Spell Casting on ARPG pp.185-86) have prerequisites.

    Given the Valinoric source of the val’Mehan Bloodline Talent, it’s possible that the answer is different for Eldritch vs. Sorcerer-Priest magic.

    #267947
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    For the Talents Rudimentary Prayers and Rudimentary Spell Casting (see ARPG pp.204-05), must the single spell selected be Tier I, or may it be any Tier?

    I infer that it should have to be a Tier I spell, but the talents are not explicit.

    I’m not sure where exactly, but it has been stated that you cannot gain T2 spells without first having at least 1 T1 spell. If you gain Rudementary Spell Casting, you gain a T1 spell. You can (at T2) learn T2 spells using Learn Spell (Ta) after this, needing to know at least one lower tier spell first, though if you take ASC/DSC you’d have to take the T1 version first.

    #267948
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    Does the ability to use Arcanum(Sorcery) untrained via the Bloodline Talent Sarish Is Known to His Chosen (ARPG p.222) count for the prerequisite of having Arcanum (Sorcery) as a trained skill?

    It is technically not trained, but since val’Mehans with that Bloodline Talent can cast spells instinctively, I can easily see it being a sufficient substitute. This question matters mostly for learning spellcasting, which val’Mehans can already somewhat do via their bloodline, but most spellcasting talents (e.g., Arcane Spell Casting on ARPG pp.185-86) have prerequisites.

    Given the Valinoric source of the val’Mehan Bloodline Talent, it’s possible that the answer is different for Eldritch vs. Sorcerer-Priest magic.

    I’m not sure exactly what you are saying here, but you technically can take Arcanum (Sorcery) at any time. Hell, it is useful to take for Arcanum: Sense Magic skill. As such, you don’t need a ‘prerequisite’ to take ranks in it. From what I know, an Elorii can take ranks in it, though if they do it’ll be a wasted skill talent since it doesn’t work with Elder Sorcery.

    #267949
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    For the spell Ward Against the Unnatural, on ARPG p.442 there is a special adaptation for the Blood tradition. Does this Blood adaptation work against any type of person or creature, or is it only against one individual Undead, Shade, or Infernal as per the base spell?

    I interpret it as being against any type of person or creature for whom the caster posses blood, but the adaptation is not explicit.

    From the text they don’t have to be one of the normal ‘unnatural’ creatures, but you do need their blood on hand to ward against them, and it would only work against that individual.

    #267950
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    Does the ability to use Arcanum(Sorcery) untrained via the Bloodline Talent Sarish Is Known to His Chosen (ARPG p.222) count for the prerequisite of having Arcanum (Sorcery) as a trained skill?

    It is technically not trained, but since val’Mehans with that Bloodline Talent can cast spells instinctively, I can easily see it being a sufficient substitute. This question matters mostly for learning spellcasting, which val’Mehans can already somewhat do via their bloodline, but most spellcasting talents (e.g., Arcane Spell Casting on ARPG pp.185-86) have prerequisites.

    Given the Valinoric source of the val’Mehan Bloodline Talent, it’s possible that the answer is different for Eldritch vs. Sorcerer-Priest magic.
    I’m not sure exactly what you are saying here, but you technically can take Arcanum (Sorcery) at any time. Hell, it is useful to take for Arcanum: Sense Magic skill. As such, you don’t need a ‘prerequisite’ to take ranks in it. From what I know, an Elorii can take ranks in it, though if they do it’ll be a wasted skill talent since it doesn’t work with Elder Sorcery.
    I’m asking not about the Arcanum skill but satisfying prerequisites for the Arcane Spell Casting talent.

    #267951
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    In the Official FAQ Version 4.3, p.5, second question on the right column, the answer mentions gaining access to the Arcane Spell Casting or Divine Spell Casting talent via a Background, Path, or Archetype “without needing to meet the requirements.” Does this answer mean that these Paths (e.g., Initiate Itinerant, Templar Itinerant), Backgrounds (e.g., Initiate of the Gods, Templar), etc. bypass the Spell Casting talents’ listed prerequisites of Prestidigitation and skill ranks?

    I had originally interpreted these Backgrounds and Paths as simply removing the [Limited] constraint for the spell casting talents yet still leaving intact the other prerequisites. Does granting access to the talent remove the prerequisites as the FAQ answer implies?

    #267952
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    When placed upon a wand, do the effects of a Sarish [Blessed] rune (from Forged in Magic, Vol. II, p.12) and a Sorcery (Eldritch) rune (from Forged in Magic, Vol. I, p.10) stack?

    If not, the effects of the Sorcery (Eldritch) seem to entirely trump the Sarish [Blessed] rune to make the later obsolete.

    #267953
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    In ARPG p. 330, the Monstrous Flaw Thrice-Bound mentions the Demonology Tradition. Should that be the Diabolism Tradition?

    #267954
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    Several val’Mehan Bloodline Talents (e.g., Sarish Is Known to His Chosen and Master of the Arcanum: see ARPG pp.222-23) grant the val the ability to cast one or more magic spells. For these spells, is the val’Mehan’s Primary Attribute Logic (as per standard Eldritch Sorcery) or Charisma (as per Sarishan Sorcerer-Priests)?

    Given the Valinoric source of the val’Mehan Bloodline Talents, I infer that it’s probably Charisma (as per Sarishan Sorcerer-Priests), but I don’t see any explicit answer in the rulebook.

    #267955
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    Three questions about ranged attacks and ranges:

    1. ARPG gives rules for Ranged Weapons, but thrown Melee Weapons seem less clear. In ARPG p. 233, Table 2-24 lists separate “Range Increments” and “Max. Range” for each ranged weapon, and p. 238 gives the rules for range. With a Melee Weapon with the Thrown quality (ARPG, p.240), is the listed range the increment or the maximum? If it is the increment, then what is the maximum range for those weapons?

    2. For a javelin, Table 2-24 (p. 233) lists the range increment listed as 20′ and max range 60′, whereas the weapon description on p. 243 lists the Thrown quality with 30′ range. Which is correct?

    3. Some Weapon Tricks (e.g., Darken the Sky and Twin Throw) list a range that is greater than the base range increment of the weapon. I presume that’s all weapon trick ranges are the maximum possible range at which the trick can be applied, right? Does the penalty for going beyond one range increment still apply when using these tricks?

    #267958
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    For the Talents Rudimentary Prayers and Rudimentary Spell Casting (see ARPG pp.204-05), must the single spell selected be Tier I, or may it be any Tier?

    I infer that it should have to be a Tier I spell, but the talents are not explicit.

    Per the Errata/FAQ v4.3, it must be a Tier 1 spell.

Viewing 15 posts - 91 through 105 (of 186 total)
  • The forum ‘Arcanis: Rules & Rulings’ is closed to new topics and replies.